# Re-Engagement Campaigns That Don't Hurt Deliverability

> Plan a re-engagement campaign: define inactive subscribers without open rates, write a short win-back sequence and choose who to stop mailing.

Canonical: https://www.cresca.xyz/blog/re-engagement-campaigns
Author: Lalit Kumar Jangid
Published: 2026-09-01
Last updated: 2026-10-28

A re-engagement campaign asks people who have gone quiet whether they still want your email. Done carefully, it wins some of them back and gives you permission to stop mailing the rest. Done carelessly, it sends a burst of email to the least interested part of your list, all at once, which is exactly the pattern that generates complaints and bounces.

This post walks through the campaign in the order you would build it: who counts as inactive, what to send, how to send it, and what to do with the people who do not respond.

## Step 1: How do you define "inactive" without leaning on opens?

Define inactivity with signals you can trust and record yourself, such as the last purchase, reply, login, support conversation or booking, plus the signup date. Store the most useful as a date field on each contact. A store might count anyone subscribed over 12 months with no purchase, reply or support ticket in the last 12 months.

The traditional definition is "hasn't opened in six months." There are two problems with it. Open tracking has become unreliable because some mail apps load images automatically, which records opens that never happened; we explain why in [why open rates stopped being reliable](https://www.cresca.xyz/blog/why-open-rates-stopped-being-reliable). And on many platforms, including Cresca, open tracking is an opt-in setting, so not every list has open data at all.

Instead, define inactivity using signals you can trust and record yourself:

- **Last purchase date** from your store or invoicing system
- **Last reply** to any of your emails
- **Last login** or account activity, if you run an app or membership
- **Signup date**, for people who joined long ago and have never bought
- **Last support conversation** or booking

Store the most useful of these as a date field on each contact. A workable definition for a store might be: subscribed more than 12 months ago, and no purchase, reply or support ticket in the last 12 months. Choose the window based on your buying cycle; a florist and a furniture shop should not use the same number.

## Step 2: Check the segment before mailing it

Inactive segments contain the oldest addresses on your list, and old addresses are the ones most likely to have been abandoned. Before sending anything:

1. Run the segment through email validation to remove bad syntax, domains with no mail server, and disposable addresses.
2. Remove anyone who has already bounced or complained. They should be suppressed already, but check.
3. Look at the size. If it is larger than your normal campaign audience, plan to send in batches (see Step 4).

Very old contacts deserve a separate judgement. If someone has had no activity for several years and you are unsure how they joined, the safest choice may be to remove them without mailing at all. The UK ICO's [consent guidance](https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/lawful-basis/consent/what-is-valid-consent/) notes that consent is likely to degrade over time and suggests refreshing it at sensible intervals.

## Step 3: How many emails should a re-engagement sequence have?

Three emails sent over two to three weeks is enough. The first reminds people who you are and why they joined, the second asks directly whether they still want to hear from you, and the third says you will stop emailing unless they reply or choose to stay.

Three emails over two to three weeks is enough. Longer sequences just mean more mail to people who are not reading.

### Email 1: The reminder

Remind them who you are and why they joined. Show one or two of the most useful things you have sent or sold recently. Keep it light and do not mention unsubscribing yet.

### Email 2: The question

Ask directly: "Do you still want to hear from us?" Give two equally clear options, one to stay subscribed and one to leave. Since you are not relying on click tracking, the "stay" option can be a link to a simple page on your site, or a request to reply with "yes." Replies are a strong positive signal and you can record them yourself.

### Email 3: The goodbye

Tell them you will stop emailing unless they take the action. Make it easy and warm. Something like: "We'll stop sending these from next week. If you'd like to stay, reply to this email or click here."

## Step 4: How fast should you send a re-engagement campaign?

Send it slowly, in batches, rather than mailing the whole inactive segment at once. Start with the most recently active people, check each batch's campaign report for bounces and complaints before sending the next, and space the batches over several days with scheduled sending. Stop and fix the cause if a batch goes badly.

This is the part of a re-engagement campaign that protects deliverability. Do not send email 1 to the entire inactive segment in one go.

- Split the segment into batches, starting with the most recently active people.
- Send the first batch and check the campaign report for bounces and complaints before sending the next.
- Space the batches over several days with scheduled sending.
- Keep your regular campaigns to active subscribers going as normal, so your overall mail stream stays mostly to engaged people.

Stop and reassess if a batch produces noticeably more bounces or complaints than your normal campaigns. A batch that goes badly is a warning about the whole segment, so fix the cause before sending the rest.

## Step 5: What should you do with contacts who do not respond?

Stop sending marketing email to anyone with no recorded response once the sequence ends, and tag them as sunset. People who replied, purchased or chose to stay go back on your main list with an updated activity date, and those who unsubscribed are already suppressed. You are only losing addresses that were not reading.

When the sequence ends, sort contacts into three groups:

| Group | What they did | What to do |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Re-engaged | Replied, purchased or chose to stay | Return to your main list; update their activity date |
| Left | Unsubscribed | Already suppressed; nothing more to do |
| Silent | No recorded response | Stop sending marketing; tag them as sunset |

Stopping mail to the silent group feels like losing subscribers. In practice, you are losing addresses that were not reading. Google's [sender guidelines](https://support.google.com/a/answer/81126) suggest periodically confirming that recipients want to stay subscribed and considering unsubscribing those who do not engage.

## Make your re-engagement campaign a routine, not a rescue

The best re-engagement campaign is a small one. Instead of waiting until a third of your list has gone quiet, run the sequence every month for people who have newly crossed your inactivity threshold.

In Cresca, keep the activity dates in [custom fields](https://www.cresca.xyz/contact-management) refreshed by a regular CSV import and build the inactive segment from them. Then send the three emails as scheduled campaigns to each month's newly inactive contacts (an [automation workflow](https://www.cresca.xyz/automated-campaigns) will do this for you once workflows launch), so only a handful of people get the sequence at a time rather than thousands at once.

Also look upstream. If one signup source keeps feeding the inactive segment, fix the source. Yahoo's [best practices](https://senders.yahooinc.com/best-practices/) recommend sending only to people who specifically asked for your mail, and a re-engagement sequence cannot fix a list built any other way.
